Asset sales street talk

Yesterday just before the Mixed Ownership Membership Bill was passed, I spent 5 hours on the streets of three communities on the Kapiti Coast with Green volunteers. I ran out of sheets on my clipboard as people asked to take petitions away and get family and neighbours to consider the issue.

Waikanae was chilly but steady, Ōtaki was good but when I went to the shops at Ōtaki Beach it was outstanding. The diversity of people choosing to sign the petition was remarkable, from elderly men and women who recalled past asset sales disasters to young guys rebuilding the street.

Two young Māori trainee carpenters just thought it was a very stupid idea, two young Pākehā mothers agreed. The lady on the bicycle who used to know my Dad was delighted to sign and so were the mother and daughter who were browsing the shops. An elderly lady who had moved to Ōtaki from Samoa wanted to take a sheet for her neighbours. Others had been wondering where they could find the petition. Not everyone is Google-savvy and they were pleased to meet a politician who wanted to talk with them about the petition and give them the opportunity to sign it.

So although Otaki Beach winds were chilly, the warmth on the street was inspiring. Even the dude who said he was going to Aus for better wages and what was the point? changed his mind and signed, because one day he would be coming home.

Levin is a larger town and much colder. At one point we saw sleet and there was a bitter whip to the wind down the long street. Fortified by hot soup I went back out on the street and met with local Green volunteers who had given their time to build the petition numbers in their home town. I had to thank them as it makes the debacle in Parliament less painfully bizarre when our members and friends are so committed to the cause.

I stood outside the Levin Mall entrance and met people who had some fairly harsh words for the Government. Unlike the one man I met in Tauranga I didn’t meet anyone who said they were planning to buy shares. One shop keeper rushed out of the Mall as she was so keen to sign and another businessman said he had been a National Party voter but this was a “terrible strategy”.

By this time my hands were frozen and it was time to go back to Parliament. I got to stand up and say “No” on behalf of the Green Party. I said it loudly for all those volunteers and all those great Kāpiti people I met one winter’s day. They deserve better.

7 Comments Posted

  1. @Paul Bailey – “what the heck they expected”

    What valid alternative do you think there was for a National voter in 2011? Put up with some partial share floats for some power companies, who regularly put up their prices anyway, or vote for tax increases, more overseas borrowing and (possibly) a flood of people heading for the airport. Yeah, what were they thinking?

    The point is, you aren’t talking just asset sales and all other things being equal. Some voters realize that you can’t always have exactly what you think you want, and you have to choose a least worst option. Those National voters who told you they were against asset sales – they made that choice.

  2. Malc says “If the government is stupid enough to sell such well performing assets…”

    Over the last five years the govt has averaged a dividend of $400m from all the SOEs. So half that (from a 49% sale) is $200m.

    For a sale price of $5-$7 billion, a $200m dividend works out at between 2.8% and 4% dividend BEFORE tax (around 2-3% after tax)

    Historically NZ has needed 2.5% more power each year, so the potential for companies to grow in NZ is minimal.

    In fact, with the recent focus on energy savings, energy efficient bulbs, heat pumps, insulation, etc, the increase in power use in 2011 was zero.

    So while the electricity companies should be safe defensive stocks, there are other safe defensive stocks that will give double to triple the return.

  3. Ditto from the Hawkes Bay Catherine… A lot of Nat voters upset with this one, but I still can’t figure out what the heck they expected.

  4. I’ve signed the petition and I think asset sales are a bad idea. But once they are for sale, I’m going to look into buying some as they will be a really good investment, so it seems silly not to.

    If the government is stupid enough to sell such well performing assets, then why not buy some shares? Surely better a kiwi buy them than some foreign bank.

  5. Good onya Catherine..

    people are lining up all around the Motu to sign, including down here in chilly Dunedin.. “NO, TO ASSET SALES !!”


Comments are closed.